Music of my flaming youth -- in the 1980s, I was force-fed a steady diet of early MTV and hair-metal bands infused with a terrible mix of pop artists that exemplify all that went wrong with popular music in the 1980s. Examples, of which there are unfortunately many: Belinda Carlisle, Lionel Richie, Motley Crue, Chicago, Billy Ocean, Debbie Gibson, Deff Leppard, Hall & Oates, Whitesnake, the Footloose and Flashdance soundtracks, as well as any number of formerly vital artists who lost their way in that time -- such as David Bowie, Rod Stewart, Eric Clapton... you get the idea. C.R.A.P!! The sort of stuff you can hear in any supermarket these days, modern-day Muzak, only more annoying.
Wendi and I grew up in the 1970s and 1980s. We were talking one day and realized that, though most music fans consider the 1980s to be a lost decade in terms of musical quality, there were actually quite a few artists/bands that we still love, whose music has withstood the test of time. Which, when you get to be our ages, is really the only test that matters.
So, for the music geek in you, I submit the following for your consideration: a few bands/artists, from the 1980s that not only didn’t suck, but made a lasting impression on your humble author. My list is not exhaustive and consists of artists commonly considered to be in the category of rock music; for instance, I excluded heavy metal and rap music (which I happen to love, but space and time precludes their inclusion -- they're subjects in and of themselves). The list is in alphabetical order, as I really don’t care for “best-of” or “top pick-a-number” lists.
Unfortunately, as often happens when I get to writing, this list rapidly spiraled out of control; not only is it not exhaustive or complete, but I have to go to bed and only got to the letter M. Oh well, here we go!!
Camper Van Beethoven
Good ol’ Camper Van, the band that virtually defined the term “college rock” in the 1980s. They had a melodic, rather folksy sound augmented by a fiddle player, which was a great contrast to their sarcastic, goofy and often surreal lyrics on songs like “Take The Skinheads Bowling” from their first album, Telephone Free Landslide Victory, and the spoken narrative “Peace & Love” from their eponymous third album. They scored a minor MTV hit in 1988 with “Eye Of Fatima”, a song about a burned-out hippie drug dealer, but they are probably best remembered for a violin-flecked cover of Status Quo’s psychedelic 1960s anthem “Pictures Of Matchstick Men.”
The band disintegrated acrimoniously in 1989, and singer David Lowry went on to form Cracker, which became one of the biggest (and most overrated) bands of the early 1990s that never approached the wry Camper Van Beethoven in wry creativity and cleverness. I mean, this is a band that recorded a version of the ENTIRETY of Fleetwood Mac’s album Tusk on a whim!
A lot of longtime fans were surprised and pleased when they reunited in 2004 for a tour and new album, New Roman Times.
The Cure
I’ve never been a huge fan of the Cure, but their contribution to the 1980’s canon of good music cannot be overlooked. Wendi is a massive Cure fan and no doubt could write a lot more than I can about their merits. Gloomy, yet surprisingly pretty songs on albums like Pornography and Disintegration cemented their reputation as torch carriers for the goth and alternative scenes.
Personally, my favorite song of theirs is the fever dream nightmare of “Lullaby”, in which Robert Smith whisper-sings over a minor key, yet surprisingly gentle accompaniment, about being eaten alive in bed by a giant spider. The video is a little lost gem from that long-ago time when MTV didn’t completely suck.
Echo And The Bunnymen
Often overlooked, EATB were always much more popular overseas, especially in their native Britain. In the USA, they are mostly known for their dreamy, yet propulsively danceable single “Lips Like Sugar” which is from their self-titled 5th album from 1987. It’s a great song, with an immortal, simple and perfect guitar riff, but this band was much deeper than their rather silly name and single-hit status in the States might imply.
For me, their song “Rescue” from EATB's first album, Crocodiles epitomizes what made them great – the lyrics “things are going wrong / won’t you come on down to my rescue?” are belted out in a strangled moan by Ian McCulloch – it’s so arresting because it’s so simple and universal… anybody who has ever felt trapped and helpless can immediately relate.
Another melodic gem, and probably their second most famous song, is “Killing Moon” which was later covered by Pavement, among others.
Gang Of Four
Progenitors of what later would become known as the genre of post-punk, Gang Of Four meshed angular, throbbing, often atonal guitar riffs with scathing, anti-capitalist lyrics. Their minimalist approach and pervasive influence can be heard in countless later bands such as Fugazi & Shellac. Unlike the bands I’ve described so far, there was very little pop music in Gang Of Four, except for the occasional disco-esque beat such as in an otherwise virulently anti-military song “I Love A Man In A Uniform”.
The band was named after the four Chinese politicos who were blamed by the Communists for the worst excesses of China’s Cultural Revolution of the late 1960s, tried and convicted in a face-saving attempt by the state. The band was not Communist, but lyrics like “the problem of leisure / what to do for pleasure / ideal of a new purchase / a market of the senses … this heaven gives me migraine” from the song “Natural’s Not In It” leave little doubt that they didn’t care to conceal their contempt for capitalism, materialism, consumerist society and the corrupt structures of contemporary power.
Their overt politics would seem didactic and pretentious if it weren’t for their inventive instrumental prowess – spiky guitars and beats propelled by a relentless, almost danceable groove that perfectly complemented their biting lyrics on songs like “A Hole In The Wallet.” Heady stuff.
Hüsker Dü
Ok let’s get this out of the way first -- Hüsker Dü was named after a Danish board game (don’t ask me why) and means “do you remember”. They were one of the most beloved American punk bands of the 1980s, and in my opinion one of the best. Their early albums are a bit unfocused, but the in-your-face angst and breakneck speed of albums like Zen Arcade (a double album recorded in just three days) are among the purest examples of indie gold.
And, unlike many punk bands, Hüsker Dü were excellent musicians – singer/shouter Bob Mould has a ringing, slashing guitar attack that is instantly recognizable, drummer/singer Grant Hart was one of the best underground drummers of his time – have one listen to Zen Arcade's epic, 14-minute closing instrumental “Reoccurring Dreams” to see what I mean.
Their final album, Warehouse: Songs & Stories, suffers from overproduction (a victim, like so many bands, of that reverbed-out 80s production) and a thin drum sound, but is their most melodic and heart-wrenchingly personal.
Sadly, this band also suffered a bitter breakup – to this day, Bob Mould and Grant Hart have barely spoken, and then mostly by slamming each other in the press. Mould found quite a bit of commercial success both with his subsequent solo albums and with Sugar, a band that recorded a few albums in the early 1990s and sounded much like the direction Hüsker Dü was going when they broke up.
Madness
A band at the forefront of the so-called 2nd wave of ska that took Britain by storm in the late 70s and early 80s, their biggest hit, “Our House” was ironically nearly free of ska influence except for the horn charts – but nevertheless a great song. These guys had a sense of humor with musical chops and respect for ska music to match.
Ministry
A lot of bands begin with a high degree of musical inventiveness. As commercial success beckons, they just can’t sustain the juice as they try to appeal to broader audiences with watered-down music that doesn’t have the same edge that made them worth listening to in the first place. Not so with Ministry – with Ministry, the conventional narrative is almost completely inverted.
Their first album, 1983’s With Sympathy, was a danceable, electro-poppy, if slightly dark affair that gave no hint that by the 21st century they would be known as the elder statesman of industrial-strength heavy metal. Quite a journey – but mid-period Ministry set the standard not for heavy metal as it is known today, but for industrial music of a particularly influential kind.
Ministry's 1988 album, The Land Of Rape & Honey, , is widely considered their best and is an ingenious fusion of the sequenced, pounding rhythms of industrial music with squalling guitars. It’s also infectious as hell – the grating but precisely processed guitar riffs and sequenced drums of “Stigmata” and “The Diety” will burn into your brain and scar you for twenty years (they did for me, anyway!). There are also all-electronic, heavy but danceable electro-industrial workouts like “Golden Dawn” and “The Abortive”.
In later years, Ministry had a long creative dry spell, particularly in the late 1990s when I pretty much wrote them off as washed up, later to recover (in fine form, although with much greater focus on heavy metal) with blistering speed metal albums like last year’s Rio Grande Blood. But they never topped The Land Of Rape & Honey, one of the definitive recordings in industrial music – a musical genre that can be surprisingly conservative and boring. Not in this case.
Whew!! And you thought the 1980s consisted entirely of disposable pop and cheesy synthesizers. I love this was just the 1st half of the alphabet! Check back again for Part II… this was 1st just the 1st half (?) of my personal, beloved alphabet of great music from the 80s. If anyone has anything to add, I would love to hear it… no matter how cheesy it is. Just don’t get mad when I roll my eyes ;-)
Stay tuned. If you dare ;-P
7 comments:
Hey Matt,
There is an opening scene to the movie "Music and Lyrics" that I think you would enjoy. It's an 80's music video that makes fun of the cheesy pop band. It was supposed to be ridiculous (and it was) but I had the song in my head for days. What can I say? It was cheesy ... and catchy! I loved it. :D
I am a stalwart fan of the twin triumvirate of the 80s: Tiffany, Debbie Gibson, and Belinda Carlisle on the feminine side; and MJ, Lionel Richie, and Wham! on the male side. Their combined portfolio puts Echo and the Bunnymen to shame. :)
J/K! Don't take it personally. So I happen to like "Shake Your Love." Can't we still be friends?
Hey, what about Carcass and Brittany Fox? :) It's a "long way to love," baby.
Here's a few more musical entities that I would guess would have made your list if you had time(for reals, bro): Prince, Metallica, Guns N Roses, R.E.M. and U2.
Matt,
You now a heck of a lot more about 80s music than I do. Two songs with very special places in my heart are "Look Away" by Chicago and "Stright Up Now Tell Me" by Paula Abdul. They used to play on our clock radio and on the bus to school in either 2nd or 3rd grade when I began to be aware of music. "Uptown Girl" by the Joel-meister also made a profound impression. Like I said, I don't know much about the 80s. I love REM, U2 and the Police, but you already knew that.
What boggles my mind is how people who were formerly good go so bad in the eighties. Musicians and the public at large, many of whom had just lived through the 60s and 70s when some people with names like John, Paul, Stevie, Jimmy and others ruled and made music that sounds as good today as the day it was released-how could they all have fallen in love with really stupid-sounding synth, drum-machined, terrible pop garbage all at the same time! This I know, I hate the "80s" sound.
Hey all so far,
Thanks for rapping with me (in the old sense of the term ;-))
Liz: I have heard that "Music & Lyrics" is a great movie, I'll have to check it out when it's on DVD. Thanx for the ref. And BTW cheesy doesn't necessarily equate with awful in my mind, though often it does. Cheesy (for me, but generally NOT for my wife!) can be so campy and ridiculous that it transcends the merely awful, but that's a subject for another post.
Mark: two words you neglected to mention when you got all Rodney King: Air Supply. That is why we can't "be friends". ;-)
Re: Carcass, you will probably never understand that band's appeal (they have a sense of humor as well as being brutally good musicians), but then Wendi doesn't either. You're off the hook.
Re: Britney Fox, I never claimed to be perfect. At least they rawked a teeny bit. OK, BF sucked then and they suck now. Geez, I was 14. What were you listening to at that age? Tiffany. Give me BF any day.... I can't believe I said that.
I was kidding about us not being able to be friends... mostly. Shake your love, man.
Jeff: I don't even remember that Chicago song (though I suspect I would if I heard it), but Paula Abdul is as inescapeable an aspect of the late 1980s as Ronald Reagan or acid-washed jeans. I'm sorry your first musical memories were formed that way. All I can say is that I'm glad it wasn't my fault.
Have to agree with you about Billy Joel though... he gets no respect from the hipsters, but songs like "Uptown Girl" are pure pop magic, delicious AND filling. I don't like everything he's done (my better half won't let me play my Billy Joel record when she's around), but I can't deny that I do have a small (and secret) soft spot for his music. Sometimes. When I have a lapse in judgement.
Good observation about the wayward direction so many vital artists went in in the 1980s. The only thing that I would add is that it is a phenomenon called "selling out". For instance, do you remember Starship? "We Built This City On Rock & Roll".... please don't puke. I only bring it up because Paul Kantner and Grace Slick made a lot of money off it... the same people who brought us the radical, stirring anti-Vietnam War anthem "Volunteers" in 1968. Even if you completely excuse politics from appearing, what in the hell was David Bowie, a vital, important and influential rock artist from the 1960s/1970s, doing recording milquetoast tripe like "Let's Dance" and "China Girl" in the 1980s?
The list goes on, but they all have one thing in common... they made a lot of MONEY doing it. That's really all we need to know as far as motivation goes.
The Baby Boom generation wrote the book on selling out. But that's a topic for another post.
The 80's were a little before my time. All I can remember is the classic song that went a little something like this...American Flag, oh yeah. American Flag, oh yeah. What a song that was. What do you think Matt?
I didn't know one of the groups you mentioned. (no surprise there) However, I for one just think you can get too technical and critical of music. Of course they made money, Matt. That is the reason they play music. Why is it a sell out if people make money doing something they like and others enjoy?
If the music is enjoyed by the people that listen to it....why else would they buy it if they didn't enjoy it, then that is enough for me.
I'm obviously not a music expert like you guys, but music with a message and a melody that is enjoyable is all I like.
Give me a little, "I left all my exes down in Texas" any day of the week over twangy, loud and totally random music and lyrics that tell me how bad a country we live in.
Dad
Oh. Man.
Father of mine, I didn't condemn selling out. I condemned playing bad music while selling out. As a former starving musician myself, I assure you that I have no problem with musicians making money from their music.
If I think their music sucks, why shouldn't I say so? And why shouldn't I sing the praises of bands and artists that have touched me?
You make my point for me: "If the music is enjoyed by the people that listen to it... then that is enough for me." I agree completely. None of the bands I mentioned are particularly obscure, and some have sold millions of records and inspired generations... apparently under your oblivious nose. So what is your problem?
You condemn music that, by your own admission, you've never even heard. I think I'm far less judgemental about music than you. I only condemn music that I've heard and don't like.
Some of the bands I wrote about you might even like, with great melodies and catchy beats.
Oh and by the way, it's "All My Ex's Live In Texas", not "I Left All My Exes Down In Texas." It's by George Strait. And I happen to like that song.
You tried to slip in a little political dig in there... "... tell me how bad a country we live in?" I could dismiss that outright, as you have never heard the music I wrote about.
But I would like to remind you that the band I think inspired your ignorant comment, Gang Of Four, was British. Their songs were angry, but clever, musically proficient, and mostly directed at British society.
You make this too easy. I would ask you what the heck you were talking about, but you already admitted that you don't know. I'll leave it at that.
Post a Comment